Road Raging - Top Tips for Wrecking Roadbuilding
Chapter 7: Know your enemy
The following section describes the main
forces that British road protesters can expect to find themselves up against,
and summarises their main roles. Suggestions of ways to counter each are
included in the "Tactics" section. Most companies and agencies will have a PR
or Corporate Communications Department, designed to absorb and deflect all
your blows. Don't waste time on them - go straight to the decision-makers and
those working directly on the scheme.
Politicians
At some point, every road will need approval from some
layer of Government. In England, trunk roads are built on the orders of the
Secretary of State for Transport; in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, the
relevant Secretary of State gives the go-ahead. Some major routes may be part
of the Trans-European Network (TEN); this means that the road will be heavily
supported (and possibly partly funded) by the European Union. Other, generally
smaller, roads are built under jurisdiction of Local Authorities.
Once the politicians have made their final decision, and the legal order to
build the road has been made, the uphill struggle to stop the paper approval
becoming grim concrete reality begins - and that's what this guide is about.
Remember that there are loads of roads which have passed all political and
legal hurdles to construction, but aren't being built. The key to adding your
road scheme to this list is to vanquish all political desire to sign the
contract and build the road.
Government will, of course, attack anyone who dares to step outside the
democratic charade to challenge its power. So expect all the usual lines:
you'll be rentamob, outsiders, anti- democratic, scroungers, eco-fascists,
etc. Join the club! Repellent as politicians are, it's important to take them
on at an early stage, to counter their arguments, to build support, and to
knock the case for the road. Unfortunately, this means playing the political
game to some extent; use them, but never trust them or rely on them!
Politicians are not brave - the more they see resistance mounting and trouble
on the horizon, the less tarmac-happy they become. However, they must be able
to back down without losing face, so think of political escape routes, such as
budget cuts. Be aware that if you raise the stakes inappropriately, or at the
wrong time, the harder it may become for politicians to publicly retreat.
Remember that different levels of government often don't agree; if the road
is planned by the State, for instance, the support / opposition of local and
parish councils will be an important factor. Identify which level of
government the pressure is coming from, and concentrate on that. There are
numerous books on lobbying politicians see Chapter xx.
Road-Building Agencies
Government always has some agency to which it
entrusts the building of roads. For English Trunk Roads, this is the Highways
Agency. For Local Authorities, it will usually be the Planning or Highways
Department. The agency is made up of professional road-builders, including
Civil Engineers and other technical and administrative staff, with no overt
political power, but whose career survival depends on building roads. So don't
waste time lobbying them, or expect to find common cause with them. The main
weakness of these agencies is their bureaucratic nature, often accompanied by
low morale. Few agency staff will venture out onto the actual road site,
except to drive about to keep an eye on things.
Financiers
Increasingly, road-building depends on corporate finance to
some degree. Private finance can fund roads totally or in part (see DBFO
below); developers can also fund a local road as part of a planning deal.
Targeting the companies or banks involved is important, especially before
construction begins - an energetic campaign might even persuade an already
nervous financier to back out. Play up the risk factors of contentious
contracts in media work. Start as soon as the identity of investors, actual or
potential, is known.
Contractors
The road-building agency must sign contracts for the
road-building, and it's the contractors who actually do the dirty work.
Contractors have responsibility to the roadbuilding agency to complete on time
and to standard. They may themselves employ any number of
subcontractors to help them do this, by taking on some specific task or
part of the project - shifting aggregate, or driving piles, for instance.
There will be all sorts of people working on the road site, from plant
operators to caterers; try and find out as soon as possible who is working for
the main contractor, who is a sub- contractor, and who is employed on a
separate subsidiary contract. It's a complex business, but knowing who works
for whom is the first step in wrecking the whole process.
Consulting Engineers
These are appointed by the roadbuilding agency,
whilst the road is still at the early planning stages, to produce a detailed
design of the road. The same consultants will usually oversee the actual
building of the road, and supervise and check contractors' work. So, they have
an obvious interest in the road finally going ahead and may actively lobby
their local contacts. The senior staff of the Consulting Engineers will
therefore be key staff on site, and co-ordinate all the different contracts
until their lovely design is finished. It is crucial to target them as much as
possible.
Surveyors
These technicians make sure the road
gets built in the right place. They wear high-visibility clothing and hard
hats on worksites, like everyone else, but often discard these when surveying
untrashed areas, to be less conspicuous. They work in pairs, threes or fours,
and may be accompanied by security guards. They carry theodolite and
reflectors, which are very expensive and delicate kit. If this gets broken,
the surveyors don't work! Sometimes, they may carry what looks like a metal
rucksack with a huge aerial. This is extremely expensive, sensitive satellite
positioning apparatus.
Surveyors will work before anything else happens; in fact, surveying is an
important part of the road planning process. There will be a burst of
surveying activity in the weeks and months leading up to the start of actual
work, and this will continue thereafter throughout the construction process.
Their work is essential, and must be accurate. For this reason, it is vital
and relatively easy to sabotage it. If you stop the surveying, the bulldozers
and chainsaws simply don't know where to go (see "Stopping Surveyors" -
Chapter 10).
Security Guards
A private security company may be appointed to keep
"trespassers" off construction sites; different contracts may use different
security firms. They act as agents of the contractors, with responsibility for
up to 24-hour protection of the works. They are therefore the people you will
encounter most directly when you venture onto a construction site. Don't treat
individual guards as the enemy. Security guards have occasionally changed
sides, and every one is a potential protester.
The higher the profile of your scheme, the higher the level of security
organisation you will face. Companies like Reliance and Group 4 (used
extensively on British road protests) have a rigid hierarchy, indicated by
differences in uniform, often by hat colour. All guards should wear
high-visibility jackets and hard hats. Some firms make their guards wear
identity numbers; if they don't, demand that they do. They are usually divided
into teams of about 15-20, led by a team leader. There will often be
specialist teams, most notably "rapid response" units, who roam about in Land
Rovers until they get called to deal with "trouble". There will be other
layers of "management" above the teams.
Guards will be mostly male, with most of the bottom level coming straight
from the dole, being paid peanuts and treated badly by their "superiors". Many
may not like the job, but are victims of financial necessity. This is the
level most likely to walk out, turn a blind eye to holes in security fences
etc, or to leak information to protesters. Hence, they are trusted with
minimal responsibility; work on sowing discontent! There will of course be a
sprinkling of psychos, rambo fantasists, and people turned down by the army or
police for being too aggressive, especially at the team leader level (see end
of Chapter 10 for ideas on dealing with violence). The most senior guards are
most likely to be army lieutenant types, and will generally avoid getting
their hands dirty.
It's worth developing a relatively peaceful (if untrusting) co-existence
with security, as you'll be seeing a lot of them, and they have every
opportunity to put the boot in, steal your gear, trash camps, etc, if
hostility rises. Of course, some may do these things anyway. Guards can be a
source of tip-offs if you cultivate them, especially as they have little
loyalty to anyone but their pay-packets. Remind them that they have an
interest in seeing protests continue for as long as possible - if the campaign
dies down, the ones at the bottom quickly get laid off. They will probably be
brainwashed to believe that you intend to do hideous things to them, and their
matey-macho culture reinforces this.
Although they're there to do what they're told, earn money, and get the
road built, they will be affected by what they see, and by how you relate to
them. Strike the balance between undermining their working efficiency at every
opportunity and not making them want to batter you. Make them hate their
bosses much more than they hate you, and try and make them understand what
you're doing and why you're there.
Legally, security guards are empowered to use "minimum reasonable force" to
remove trespassers from private land, and are supposed to ask you to leave
before touching you. In practice, they'll grab you as soon as they catch you
on a work site, and chuck you off. Don't expect the police to protect you from
"unreasonable" force. Guards have no more legal power than anyone else when
they venture off the private land they are protecting (eg. onto the public
highway) - use this to your advantage.
Private Detectives
The DoT has used private detectives to
photograph, spy on, serve legal papers on, film, and generally harass
activists since the protests at Twyford Down in 1992. One firm, Bray's of
Southampton, has cornered the market in this sad and shady speciality. It is
highly likely that you will face some similar type of snooping, which will be
separate from the police's evidence gathering - although pooling of
information is almost guaranteed.
They're not doing this for your benefit - the information they collate can
do nothing but harm you, sooner or later, and you will have no control or
knowledge of what is done with it. We suggest you make life as difficult and
unpleasant as possible for them at every opportunity.
Tree Surgeons & Chainsaw Operators
Tree-felling specialists will
be involved at an early stage, as they try to obliterate everything living
from the route of the road. They generally work in pairs; one to operate the
saw, plus a mate to carry spare petrol and pull vegetation out of the way,
etc.
In evictions, a tree "surgeon" will go up in trees to lop branches, either
climbing with spiked boots, or riding in a cherry-picker. Their job
theoretically doesn't include pulling protesters from trees, but they often
do. Most chainsaw operators will be based relatively locally. They wear hard
hats and protective trousers, boots and visors.
Bailiffs and Sheriff's Officers
These characters only crawl out into
the sunlight when they arrive to evict you from your camp, treehouse or squat.
They are court servants usually working for the Undersheriff, who has legal
responsibility for enforcing the court order. As the Undersheriff is
invariably a smug fat solicitor who boosts his career and earns extra fees by
evicting the underclass from their miserable homes, he needs minions to
actually do the dirty work. Bailiffs must be "sworn in" as court officers to
be legally empowered to evict. They should ask you to leave first, and then
may use "reasonable force" to remove you when you refuse. The bailiffs you are
likely to meet will be very clued up about protester tactics, lock-ons etc.
Once you have been removed from the site by bailiffs, their legal power over
you ends. On site, they generally wear boiler suits and riot-cop style
helmets.
Climbers
As tree defence has become more sophisticated, trained
specialist climbing bailiffs have been recruited to gain access to the trees
and walkways, and belay you out of them. In Britain, they have all been
employed by the same firm - RTA of Chesterfield (see Chapter 16) - and carved
out a cosy little niche for themselves in this despicable and lucrative work.
Once sworn in, their legal powers are the same as those of bailiffs, and they
are even less popular. They are unmistakable with their rock helmets, anoraks
and climbing gear.
Potholers
If you dig tunnels, you may encounter potholing specialists,
employed by the Sheriff to evict underground protesters. They dress in black,
and wear balaclavas and helmets. Little is currently known about these
publicity-shy characters.
Police
No matter what your previous views on the British police, after
being involved in a direct action campaign you will realise that their
function there is to protect the interests of big business and the State. The
friendly bobby who told you the time when you were a child suddenly becomes a
sadistic nutter who will punch you if you dare get in the way. The reason why
they were friendly before? Because asking the time doesn't threaten the State!
When you step over that line from being passive and obedient to actually
challenging things, you see the real side of the police. Their essential and
historic role is to ensure that nothing changes.
As a campaign, you'll have to think about how to deal with the police as
they will turn up at everything you do - like a bad smell. You may consider
doing some "liaison" with them. But remember that behind every smiling face of
the "nice cop" is a whole army of the real police - Special Branch, M15 and
friends - tapping campaign phones and writing reports. Basically, they exist
to screw up your plans! Always have a cynical attitude to the police, and
never trust them.
This may all sound very negative, and some would argue that all cops are
individuals and should be treated as such. The trouble is that when working
they are not individuals. They are part of an army and follow the orders of
people who you don't get a chance to reason with. They always do follow
orders.
The police have a strict hierarchy and there will be a cop in charge on the
ground at all times. If you need to speak to the police, make sure you speak
to the most senior one, not to someone who has no command or control. All
police should have identification (numbers or symbols) on their shoulders and
from this you can work out their rank.
Local Road Supporters
There will be a whole host of local rogues who,
for various reasons, actively support the construction of the road, although
they aren't directly involved in building it. They include:
Residents Lobby Groups
Active pro-road campaign groups are becoming
more prevalent. They are generally underpinned by people who have something
definite to gain if the road is built (e.g. they live on a road which will be
"relieved" by the new road). They are often mobilised or supported by
professional pro-road lobbyists like the British Road Federation, and will use
the "local people want the road - that's democracy" line to the maximum.
Groups like this are at their busiest when the road seems most likely to be
cut.
Businesses
Cartels such as the local Chamber of Commerce will often
support a road because it smells lots of tasty deals on the horizon. These
groups often have serious local influence.
Landowners
Those who stand to make money from development
opportunities as a spin-off from the road will support it. Again, they often
wield considerable local clout.
We could go on for ages, of course, and mention local media, magistrates,
pub landlords, vigilantes, and the numerous other local factions who will do
their best to make your life difficult. However, the most important thing to
be aware of is how all the local pro-roadies link up to present a web of
influence. This may be done by forming a formal group, along with local
politicians. The Newbury Bypass Forum, for instance, manipulated local opinion
effectively in 1995, presenting a vociferous political lobby to pressurise
national government to approve the Newbury Bypass. The most important links
will be behind the scenes - local businesses, landowners and politicians all
have their hands in each others' pockets. Expose the vested interests!
Contract Award Procedures
Firstly, the contract will usually be
advertised by the roadbuilding agency in the trade press, inviting contractors
to "pre-qualify" for the contract. This means demonstrating their ability and
credentials to successfully complete the contract. This stage is sometimes
omitted for preliminary contracts.
The roadbuilding agency will then select a shortlist of contractors (often
six) who will be invited to submit bids. These contractors will prepare a
detailed price estimate of their costs in completing the contract. This
represents a significant investment of time and money by each contractor, who
must submit their bid (or "tender") by a certain date stated by the
roadbuilding agency. The agency will then work through the bids, eliminating
them until it awards the contract - often to the lowest bidder.
The construction press will have the latest news on contracts, including
which contractors have been shortlisted, and rumours about who is most likely
to win. The roadbuilding agency will make an official announcement when it's
ready, but the contract will have been sewn up before then. Once a main
contract has been signed, stopping the road becomes very much harder. We
suggest putting a lot of energy and thought into sabotaging the contract award
procedures (see ideas within Chapter 10).
A Note About Dbfo & Private Finance
New publicly-funded trunk
roads are currently rare in Britain, and private finance is becoming more
important. In many other parts of the world, it is the usual means of funding
infrastructure. We mention it here because private finance procedures may vary
from those described above. In particular, the UK system of DBFO (Design,
Build, Finance, Operate) is very different; bidders must form a consortium,
comprising civil engineers, consulting engineers, financiers, traffic
consultants, and legal advisers, to bid for a contract.
The contract involves some new scheme planning and construction, but also
maintenance of a stretch of highway for some years, all at the consortium's
own cost. At the end of this time, the consortium will be reimbursed by the
Treasury according to a number of factors, including traffic levels - a reward
for generated traffic! The main difference with a DBFO contract is its greater
scope and complexity, and a higher burden of risk on contractors. If the road
you're fighting is DBFO or private finance, we suggest exploiting all the
extra issues raised. For background info on DBFOs contact Transport 2000 or
ALARM UK (see Chapter 16).
This book is now out of print. You might be able to get a copy from a UK
library by ordering on the inter-library loans scheme.
Road Alert!
EMAIL: info@roadalert.org.uk